AAA Inspector Rating Details (scale 1-5)
AAA Inspector Notes
Come to Shelter Island for the lovely views and stay for the delectable food this spot has to offer. A separate menu is offered in the bar and lounge area, but all selections are prepared with the same care and attention. Traditional, nautical décor nicely complements the overall theme and decadent specialty seafood dishes. Non-seafood selections also are available like coffee-rubbed beef short ribs and pan-roasted sage-brined chicken.