New Sheridan Hotel

AAA Inspector Rating
8.7
Wonderful
67 Guest Ratings
231 W Colorado Ave
Telluride, CO 81435- Map It
Photos
X
AAA Inspector Notes
Built in 1891, this hotel offers attractive rooms with custom furnishings and heated bathroom tile floors. Due to the property's historic nature, standard rooms are on the small side. Public areas feature original woodwork enhanced with colorful paintings of the hotel and town. Unwind while taking in mountain views and sipping a beverage from the rooftop bar. The central location makes shopping and dining a breeze. Smoke free premises. 26 units. 3 stories, interior corridors.

Amenities & Services

WiFi
Swimming Pool
Pets Allowed
Fitness Center
ECO Friendly
Electric Charging
Accessible
Business Center
Type
Historic Boutique Hotel
Location
At SR 145 (Colorado Ave) and Oak St. 231 W Colorado Ave 81435 (PO Box 980).
Parking
street only.
Dining & Entertainment
New Sheridan Chop House, see separate listing, full bar.
Room Amenities
no A/C, high-speed Internet, wireless Internet, safes. Some: refrigerators.
Sports & Recreation
trails, massage.
Guest Services
valet laundry, room service.
Terms
seasonal, check-in 4 pm.

Guest Ratings

OVERALL GUEST SCORE
Wonderful
Based on Ratings from 67 guests
Showing reviews 1 - 5 of 47
8.3
Bev
Very Good
young couple
04-21-2017
Pros: Beautifully decorated. Great bar & restaurant. Terrific location. Nice staff. Classic boutique style.
Cons: No laundry facilities - told laudromat was 2 miles out of town. Some areas of restaurant needed cleaning (spills on walls and chairs needed dusting.) Go to basemet for ice. Gret room for two but only 1 chair and no table for room service use.
7.9
Montana
Good
review category group of friends
03-14-2017
Pros: The location was amazing, walking outside and being right downtown with beautiful mountain views all around was amazing and the gondola being only 2 blocks away made it even better. The room was very clean, beautiful and the bathroom was lovely. The hotel itself is charming and has a great old time feeling to it, it was quite beautiful inside!
Cons: The room was the smallest hotel room I've ever stayed in, i couldn't believe we paid what we paid for how small that room was. Also, on their website they have pictures of hot tubs on the roof and advertise that there are 'bathrobes in each room that many people wear to and from the hot tubs' but when I called the front desk to see how late the hot tubs were open till the guy said they didn't have hot tubs, later on we went to go up on the roof deck, the door was locked but we could clearly see that there were hot tubs up there. I'm just curious why the guy didn't say the hot tubs aren't open right now instead? Weird.
7.1
Namaste
Good
family with young children
03-07-2017
Pros: Excellent location for skiing!
Cons: room was quite small. No hot tub :-(
9.2
Anonymous
Wonderful
family with young children
03-06-2017
Pros:
Cons: The band was very loud and played until about 2 am. The hot tub on the roof is "out of service" and it looks like it's been that way for a while.
9.6
John
Exceptional
young couple
01-22-2017
Pros: The hotel itself was wonderful! Location, staff, food and food value was great. Even a 20% discount for Breakfast and lunch for guests.
Cons: Sometimes you take the good with the bad... Location right in the center of Telluride on the street comes with Beautiful views and great people watching... but.... be warned street noise and late night partiers when the bars close may wake you from your peaceful sleep. THIS IS NOT the Hotels fault and the benefits certainly out-weighed the people having fun outside for a few hours. Sometimes it was entertaining!
Showing reviews 1 - 5 of 47