New Sheridan Hotel

AAA Inspector Rating
8.7
Wonderful
67 Guest Ratings
231 W Colorado Ave
Telluride, CO 81435- Map It
AAA Inspector Rating Details (scale 1-5)
4.3
Overall
Room4.3
Bath4.0
Public Areas4.4
AAA Inspector Notes
Inspector Pick (Classification): The hotel decor reflects its historic past while creating a modern feel. I enjoy the rooftop bar in the summer and the cozy wood lounge in the winter!
Built in 1891, this hotel offers attractive rooms with custom furnishings and heated bathroom tile floors. Due to the property's historic nature, standard rooms are on the small side. Public areas feature original woodwork enhanced with colorful paintings of the hotel and town. Unwind while taking in mountain views and sipping a beverage from the rooftop bar. The central location makes shopping and dining a breeze. Smoke free premises. 26 units. 3 stories, interior corridors.

Amenities & Services

WiFi
Swimming Pool
Pets Allowed
Fitness Center
ECO Friendly
Electric Charging
Accessible
Business Center
Type
Historic Boutique Hotel
Location
At SR 145 (Colorado Ave) and Oak St. 231 W Colorado Ave 81435 (PO Box 980).
Parking
street only.
Dining & Entertainment
New Sheridan Chop House, see separate listing, full bar.
Room Amenities
no A/C, wireless Internet, safes. Some: high-speed Internet.
Sports & Recreation
trails, massage.
Guest Services
room service.
Terms
seasonal, check-in 4 pm.

Guest Ratings

OVERALL GUEST SCORE
Wonderful
Based on Ratings from 67 guests
Showing reviews 1 - 5 of 50
10.0
Verified Hotel Guest
Exceptional
Traveling as Couple
01-12-2018
Pros: Centrally located, historic hotel, excellent staff and services.
Cons: We had to go back home.
10.0
Terry
Exceptional
Traveling as Couple
01-12-2018
Pros: The hotel was clean, the staff was outstanding and very accommodating. The room was comfortable and the bathroom was well appointing with great fixtures and even a heated floor. The convenience of have a restaurant on premise with fantastic food.
Cons: I can't say it wasn't ok but I would have liked higher water pressure.
10.0
Chris
Exceptional
Family with Teens
01-12-2018
Pros: Hotel was charming and staff was great!
Cons:
8.0
Lisa K.
Very Good
Traveling as Couple
01-12-2018
Pros: Great location and great staff. Very friendly and accommodating. Loved the rooftop bar too!
Cons:
5.0
Verified Hotel Guest
Fair
Business Traveler
01-12-2018
Pros: 1. Extraordinarily friendly and helpful staff. 2. The restaurant (Chop House) had excellent food. 3. The morning coffee probably is the best 'institutional' coffee. 4. The history and ambiance is great. 5. Very comfortable bed.
Cons: 1. It is overpriced. 2. It does not have air conditioning. You have to open the windows to cool the room - allowing street noise. 3. The elevator was extremely slow.
Showing reviews 1 - 5 of 50