Classic. This iconic restaurant is a bit hidden on the second floor of the Chicago Athletic Hotel. To find it, you must pass the hotel front desk and then move through an upscale game room to the entry door. The dining room is decorated in polished cherrywood and offers a clubby vibe with very low lighting. The menu features excellent duck, lamb chops, Prime steak, seafood and raw options like bigeye tuna, watermelon carpaccio and beef tartare. You'll need your cellphone's flashlight to see the menu.