Set back from the highway on a hillside, this hotel features spacious rooms with comfortable beds and an on-site bowling facility. The hotel requests that travelers call ahead to confirm the availability of the pool.
Smoke free premises. 76 units. 2 stories (no elevator), interior corridors.
The hotel is old and dated. But it's the only place in the area with a pool, which is smaller than it looks.
Pros: The beds weren't bad compared to some hotels we have stayed in.
Cons: I paid extra for a mountain view but instead it looked over the parking lot.
5.4
Anonymous
Fair
family with young children
10-09-2017
I would not go back...
Pros: People at the front desk were very friendly. Beds were comfortable.
Cons: Most of the lights in the room didn't work. There was hair in the bathtub. When we turned on water in the tub, rust chunks came out. One of the washcloths was stained.
5.8
Ashley
Okay
young couple
10-08-2017
Okay
Pros:
Cons:
3.8
Nora
Poor
family with young children
10-03-2017
Poor
Pros:
Cons:
5.0
Disappointed
Fair
young couple
10-03-2017
This would not be my...
Pros: Light bulb was not working and maintenance man came fairly quickly and fixed.
Cons: Room could have been cleaner. Long hairs on floor in bathroom and on bedspread; my husband and I have very short white hair.
7.1
Anonymous
Good
young couple
09-26-2017
Good
Pros:
Cons:
5.8
Arnold
Okay
solo traveller
09-26-2017
Okay
Pros:
Cons:
6.3
Brenda
Pleasant
family with young children
09-25-2017
Warning call ahead make sure...
Pros: The pool was right outside of our room and we had access to several fine dining resturants.
Cons: Because we were off of the pool area the pool shut down at 10 pm therefore we knew the kids playing in the pool and the noise would end. Echo chamber effect if there are alot of people. The Friday evening staff allowed a wedding party with their own alcohol into the pool area. We were woken up at 11:30 by the drunk group that had to get up in the morning for their wedding. When I asked why Managment allowed a Private party in the pool area until 12 am. They stated they were guests also who paid for the their rooms and that they would be done at 12. At 12:15 they were gone. WHY was the private party not put in the Resturant/bar? Or the bowing alley that was still open. Because the guy in the sweat shirt hoody behind the desk was part of the party and allowed them their. NONE of us hot much sleep that night.
2.5
Vincent
Poor
review category group of friends
09-25-2017
overpriced
Pros: nothing
Cons: answers above
3.8
Anonymous
Poor
review category group of friends
09-22-2017
Never sgain
Pros:
Cons: The first room smelled like a cess pool backed up. 2nd room had a dirty tissue when we pulled back the sheets. The breakfast room was never cleaned from the day before, it was so dirty. The morning attendant was sleeping and there was no coffee made.
5.8
Therese
Okay
family with young children
09-21-2017
It was a pleasant stay...
Pros: It was close to suny cobleskill
Cons: Dated and the mattresses were uncomfortable
7.1
Kaymed96
Good
family with young children
09-20-2017
Good
Pros:
Cons:
7.5
Lori
Good
young couple
09-20-2017
Okay
Pros:
Cons: Restaurant was closed again. The 1st time we stayed, restaurant was closed. We found out this time that restaurant is not opened on days we stayed.
Also rooms need to be updated. Beds are uncomfortable for more than 1 night stay and when in shower, our ceiling leaked water over shower? Also water dripped all night from shower handle. Rooms need to be updated for price you pay. $165 for a Friday night in Cobleskill NY? You can find a cheaper room on Long Island with updated amenities.
9.6
Shannon
Exceptional
young couple
09-18-2017
I would definitely come back!
Pros: Everyone there was accommodating and kind.
Cons: The bed were slightly uncomfortable.
3.8
Jeremy
Poor
young couple
09-17-2017
Waste of money.
Pros: Lots of parking, close to many stores/restaurants
Cons: Pile of garbage behind the nightstand. Internet never worked. Called front desk twice and visited once. All 3 times the staff said "it's working up here". Didn't seem to want to fix the problem. Left a note for the manager with my number looking for a possible discount. He's never called. Screw this dump
3.8
Sabrina
Poor
family with young children
09-14-2017
Dinner was ok
Pros: The first room they gave us wasn't even clean yet. Open door and smelled and bed where a mess garbage towels everywhere very dirty.
Cons: Not much . Pool wasn't open late enough.
2.9
Anonymous
Poor
family with young children
09-13-2017
Close to Howe Caverns
Pros: Having the pool was the only reason I booked it
Cons: Dirty facilities, staff were either nonexistent or really didn't want to be there.
Continental breakfast was in a tiny space, again not really clean, no coffee available, pastries, muffins looked days old.. needless to say, we checked out shortly afterwards and stopped at Dunkin.
10.0
Tzigi
Exceptional
family with young children
09-11-2017
Great Hotel
Pros: Great Hotel, Excellent Facilities with Heated Pool & Bowling
Cons:
10.0
Jennifer
Exceptional
family with young children
09-09-2017
Exceptional
Pros:
Cons:
3.8
Charles
Poor
young couple
09-08-2017
These people are thieves.
Pros: Nothing. As soon as you walk in the door it had the smell of sewerwater. We payed an extra 25 dollars for our three pound teacup Chihuahuato stay. She was perfectly behaved and was brought outside regularly.Next week we got a 300 hundred dollar charge for clean up charges. Avoidthis dump. The animals are better behaved than the managers. Shame onyou. The room was a dump. Calling Better Business Bureau. Humansshouldn't be staying there let alone animals. My dog acts betterthan the people running this dump.
Cons: Everything. How dare you charge me for nothing that was wrong. If youwalk in here you'll know something is wrong. Run away fast.
3.8
Erin
Poor
young couple
09-07-2017
Don't stay here if you...
Pros: Little Italy nearby had good food but had to take it to go as flies were everywhere inside restaurant.
Cons: Bed was awful, water pressure was bad and temperature fluctuated, staff was always missing from front counter, while we were in pool staff started refilling the pool with freezing cold water, card reader to get in to building and room was a gamble on if it would work.
2.9
Virgil
Poor
young couple
09-05-2017
Very poor
Pros:
Cons:
3.3
Tammie
Poor
young couple
09-05-2017
NOT HAPPY AT ALL, DISGUSTED...
Pros: There was not much. We went to their restaurant and to play a few games of bowling. The waitress was amazing and the young man running the pool hall was very nice too.
Cons: They did not have our registration that we did through booking.com. Took an excessive amount of time to get them to find the registration and change them amount. The pool was VERY green, there was brown long hair in the bathroom counters and sink. Both myself and my boyfriend have light blonde hair. The mattresses were just box springs, there was NO mattress and we had to take all the blankets off the other bed to use as cushions on ours to make sleeping at all even possible at all.
Then there was a woman we met while bowling, who said someone tried to break into her room with a knife the night before and the cops were called and they got reprimanded to not offer help to the woman that was screaming in the hall after this happened. I asked for my money back or a good portion of it back and they wouldn't even do that. This room was $165, We got a room at the comfort in for $80 the next day because we would not stay there and it was like heaven.
5.8
Anthony
Okay
family with young children
09-03-2017
Okay
Pros:
Cons:
7.1
Anonymous
Good
family with young children
09-02-2017
Good
Pros: Pool
Cons: Breakfast
9.2
Linda
Wonderful
family with young children
08-30-2017
Superb
Pros: They have a very unique pool area. Some of the rooms open right up to it, which seemed really convenient for families with younger children.
Cons:
6.3
Rita
Pleasant
family with young children
08-29-2017
Pleasant
Pros:
Cons:
7.1
Denise
Good
family with young children
08-28-2017
Everything was comfortable except the...
Pros:
Cons: The A/C didn't work the same at night, didn't stay cold, they seemed to take it over remotely at night.
4.6
Robert
Disappointing
young couple
08-28-2017
Probably not going to stay...
Pros: It's one of only 2 hotels in the area, so if you want to stay in Cobleskill, there's not many options. The hotel is old, not updated and on the dirty side. The room next to us had 2 dogs that kept barking. Our room smelled like dogs. I wouldn't recommend this hotel, but as I said, there aren't many other options in the area.
Cons: Cleanliness
2.9
Jlu
Poor
family with young children
08-25-2017
Drive to Albany Instead
Pros: Halls and room were filthy with sawdust and cobwebs. Tub was dirty and stained. Pool was closed. Building is much more outdated than what appeared in photos.
Cons: We were there for 10 minutes and immediatelyasked for refund after seeing condition of the room. The front desk receptionist was friendly...she apologized and explained the sawdust was from them drilling for Internet...but a manager was rude and short-tempered during my 3 weeks of billing issues.
7.9
Medusakat
Good
family with young children
08-25-2017
This hotel is adequate for...
Pros: This is the second time we have stayed at the Rodeway Inn near the Cobleskill campus. Both times the staff was very helpful and professional. We enjoyed the unique pool. I would stay again, however.
Cons: But, were disappointed that the small pool is actually a toddler pool, not a hot tub. The wi-fi didn't work well both times. Other than that, is a nice place with a bowling alley, restaurant on-site.
3.8
Talia
Poor
young couple
08-25-2017
Bad service dirty rugs dogs...
Pros: Close yo the college
Cons: Dogs barked all day n night
Bowling ally lanes all broken had to change lanes 4 times
5.0
Debra
Fair
family with young children
08-24-2017
It was a bed to...
Pros: The showers were nice
Cons: The hallway carpets had bleach stains, the walls throughout building had water stains, the continental breakfast was unwelcoming....understatement..
7.9
Laurie
Good
family with young children
08-24-2017
Good price. But will not...
Pros:
Cons: Room dirty. Sticky drawer, bible covered in questionable sticky substance. Dead bugs and dirt under the sink. Hair in the bathtub.
7.1
Margaret
Good
solo traveller
08-23-2017
Good
Pros:
Cons:
7.1
Erin
Good
family with young children
08-22-2017
Good
Pros:
Cons: Furniture needs to be moved when vacuuming
3.8
Jan
Poor
solo traveller
08-21-2017
There was a leak in...
Pros:
Cons:
2.9
Anonymous
Poor
family with young children
08-15-2017
Very poor
Pros:
Cons:
7.5
Chris
Good
family with young children
08-10-2017
Good overnight stay
Pros: The room was nice and clean. they had a bowling alley on site! Great way to keep kids occupied in the evening.
Cons:
3.3
David
Poor
solo traveller
08-09-2017
Poor
Pros:
Cons:
6.3
Anonymous
Pleasant
family with young children
08-07-2017
Surly clerk, nice pool.
Pros: Nice indoor pool. I would normally not go into an indoor pool, but this one was clean and inviting. Swam in morning with kids. I like that they allow dogs!!!! Very helpful.
Cons: I called the day before arrival and requested early check in. They said they were full and it would be tough, but then told me I could check in at 1pm. When I arrived at 1pm, I was told that they could only check me in at 3pm. The clerk (who was not the one who gave me permission over the phone) was surly. He did not give me a better answer. We had to return at 3pm. Tough when traveling with a dog. I ran into him the next day. He was not the happy, outgoing staff member that one would want.
The continental breakfast was not at all inviting. The hallways smell
7.5
Janice
Good
family with young children
08-05-2017
Good
Pros: The location was convenient. There are lots of stores and food options within walking distance.
Cons: The restaurant hours were not convenient. It was closed on Sunday. The refridgerator wasn't cleaned out well. I recleaned it before we unpacked our things.
9.6
James
Exceptional
review category group of friends
08-02-2017
Exceptional
Pros:
Cons:
8.8
Dodgeem990613
Excellent
review category group of friends
07-31-2017
Fabulous
Pros: Rooms, staff, restaurant, bowling alley
Cons: Pool was not 24 hours, free breakfast. Extremely drunk patron in bar and bowling alley.
7.5
Daniel
Good
family with young children
07-30-2017
Good
Pros:
Cons:
9.6
Anonymous
Exceptional
family with young children
07-28-2017
Exceptional
Pros: breakfast/bowling alley
Cons: some of the restaurant food
4.2
Joe
Disappointing
young couple
07-28-2017
not very good
Pros:
Cons: no Wifi the whole week end and cold showers both days we were there
4.6
Charles
Disappointing
young couple
07-27-2017
Stay away
Pros: The hallways were very dirty, the rooms carpet was stained and smelled, the bed and pillow were nice, we were supposed to stay two nights, we only stayed one night as we drove eight hours we left the following day, for a 130.00 a night the place could've been much cleaner, we only had four hours to drive to get home so we left early, the hotel needs major updating in the bathroom tile, new rugs and needs major cleaning inside and out the hotel Windows are fogged on the inside, I would not stay there again.!! Ever
Cons: We didn't like anything about the hotel Everything
8.3
Donna
Very Good
review category group of friends
07-24-2017
Excellent food and service
Pros: The kitchen and bar staff were wonderful. The cook was excellent. Great food and served by great people.
Cons:
10.0
Stacy
Exceptional
family with young children
07-24-2017
Family friendly and great location
Pros: Love that there is a bowling alley and diner on the premises... the pool is very kid friendly, not too deep and perfect temperature... it's located in a great area and the staff was great too
;detailController.handleFacebook('SEO','Rodeway Inn & Suites', '56482', 'ACCOMMODATION', '2', '', '', 'http://tdr.aaa.com/tdr-images/images/property_photo/accommodation/56482H1.jpg', 'Cobleskill', '', '', '', '');){kind=link}
;detailController.handleTwitter('SEO','Rodeway Inn & Suites', '56482', 'ACCOMMODATION', '2', '', 'http://tdr.aaa.com/tdr-images/images/property_photo/accommodation/56482H1.jpg', 'Cobleskill', '', '', '', '');){kind=link}
