Historic. This classic steakhouse was originally a men's pipe-smoking club in 1885. The décor features lovely 19th-century oak walls, old playbills, photos and a ceiling decorated with thousands of clay pipes. The menu offers a fine selection of prime cuts of beef, chicken and seafood dishes like live Maine lobsters. As a classic manly bastion, this place ranks among the very top in the city. The dining room and classic cocktail bar are like museum exhibits honoring the glory days of the Herald Square theater district. The clay pipe collection is the largest in the world.