The American Hotel

AAA Inspector Rating
45 Main St
Sag Harbor, NY 11963- Map It
Phone: (631) 725-3535
AAA Inspector Rating Details (scale 1-5)
3.7
Overall
Food3.8
Service3.4
Decor3.9
AAA Inspector Notes
An elegant experience awaits at the dining room of this 1846 hotel. Period artwork, hanging plants and a wood-burning fireplace add to the charm. With an emphasis on French-American classics, the menu offers lobster bisque, Long Island duckling and flounder amandine; the expansive caviar selection typically includes flying fish roe and Mississippi paddlefish caviar. Servers guide you through the extensive wine list.
$16-$48
French
Jct SR 114, just s. 45 Main St 11963
street only.
Closed some major holidays.
Fine Dining. Breakfast, lunch and dinner served. Full bar, patio dining.