Gatsby's on the Bay

AAA Inspector Rating
695 Bay St
Staten Island, NY 10304- Map It
(718) 442-8729
AAA Inspector Rating Details (scale 1-5)
2.8
Overall
Food2.6
Service3.0
Decor3.1
AAA Inspector Notes
Close to the transformational development in nearby St. George, Bay Street has emerged as a flourishing downtown location for slightly edgy nighttime activity on the North Shore of the island. The Prohibition-era decor is romantic and colorful, especially when live jazz plays on the weekends around dinnertime. Seafood risotto, fresh pasta and steak highlight a compact menu. A grand oak bar serves cocktails and is a prime spot to have a libation and unwind as you listen to the jazz. Call ahead to ensure that the dining room is open to the public on weeknights; the room may be booked for a private party. Book your table ahead of time for the live jazz events on weekends.
$18-$30
New Seafood Steak
Between Vanderbilt Ave and Broad St; in Stapleton. 695 Bay St 10304
on-site and street.
Closed Mon.
Casual Dining. Dinner served. Full bar. Entertainment.