Perfect for both the business and leisure traveler, this budget-friendly property offers comfortable accommodations and is close to the interstate.
Smoke free premises. 63 units, some efficiencies. 2 stories (no elevator), interior corridors. Accessibility (Call).
Cons: Pillows were too cushy/gave me a stiff neck.
Also blood on the sheets!
Also veeeeryyy pricey for a hotel in the middle of nowhere -- I've stayed at cheaper hotels in Manhattan!
9.6
Melissa
Exceptional
family with young children
09-06-2016
Pros: The place was comfortable, clean and we'll kept. The staff was very helpful, friendly and courteous.
Cons: Nothing really
7.9
Anonymous
Good
young couple
09-04-2016
Pros: comfortable bed
Cons:
6.7
Sherry
Pleasant
mature couple
08-31-2016
Pros: The staff was courteous.
Cons: The eggs were terrible, the waffle maker was broken, &the jacuzzi was out of service, very disappointing!
7.5
Michael
Good
family with older children
08-25-2016
Pros:
Cons: Outdoor seating, there could be more.
5.4
Frank
Fair
solo traveller
08-23-2016
Pros: The woman that checked me in was very friendly and gave me local directions. She also said if I got lost that she would be on duty for hours... and, could be reached on the phone.
Cons: I was given a room with an unpleasant odor. I learned that the staff was aware of the problem... but, they wanted me to complain before giving me another room.
10.0
Donna
Exceptional
family with older children
07-11-2016
Pros: Staff was very helpful, especially Michelle.
Cons: Could not get the Wi-Fi to work, plus the TV didn’t have enough channels.
7.0
Verified Hotel Guest
Good
Senior Traveler
06-28-2016
Pros: We found the room to have most everything that we needed. They are the processes of replacing the furniture and carpets...They are easily accessible to Rt. 87. The complimentary/continental breakfast was sufficient including sausage & scrambled eggs.
Cons: I did see '1' bug in the bathroom that appeared to be a bed-bug or tick...I checked the mattresses and found 'none'... I understand that is rather common these days. I would still stay there, again.
6.7
Sarah
Pleasant
mature couple
06-23-2016
Pros: Very clean, very close to highway.
Cons: Pool was disgusting. Jacuzzi was broken. No smoking rooms.
8.8
Carol
Excellent
mature couple
06-19-2016
Pros: Size of room and cleanliness
Cons: I booked 2 nights with bookings.com but when I checked in, the person at the desk must have put me in wrong. At 3am of the first night, I got a bill for one night. When I went to the desk, they showed me booked for second night, but I had to check out by turning in my key card. I had to check in again my showing ID and giving my credit card again; then I was issued new key cards. Time-consuming and boring!
7.1
Lucy
Good
mature couple
06-12-2016
Pros: nice breakfast, local limited food options
Cons: motel was being refurbished during our visit rugs being replaced ,painting etc we still paid a rate higher than expected…. a price break would have made the mess more tolerable…..
7.1
David
Good
mature couple
05-20-2016
Pros: An average older motel next to the Thruway. Rooms were adequate and clean. A big plus was the complimentary self serve breakfast with a waffle station, eggs, toast, bacon and sausage. The Indoor pool was also a plus. If we are in the area again we will stay there.
Cons: Paper thin walls and Thruway traffic were the only negatives during our stay.
9.6
Patricia
Exceptional
family with older children
04-27-2016
Pros: Customer service was excellent,staff was very friendly.
Cons: The TV was blurry and when booking rooms online it doesn't state that they will be putting hold on card when you arrive which makes nosense when paying cash. The front desk worker did allow me to just pay cash but it was still confusing.
8.3
A
Very Good
solo traveller
04-23-2016
Pros: Buffet breakfast was more than adequate. I took mine back to my room as I was traveling alone and did not want to take up a table.
Upon my arrival in the evening I ordered from a restaurant down the street. The food was very good. I was able to store the leftovers in the refrigerator that was in the room. That was handy.
Cons:
9.2
Yvonne
Wonderful
review category group of friends
04-13-2016
Pros: breakfast was good , eggs cooked just right not rubbery and dry like last time there. Always friendly staff and very helpful. Will stay again
Cons: the roll pillow dirty , didn't want to touch to take off bed
the bed not as comfortable as others in this room , or the pillows , meaning other rooms here , maybe its close to time to change room 102
7.1
Cre
Good
review category group of friends
03-02-2016
Pros: Loved how soft the bed was and the water pressure. Staff was very helpful in changing accommodations.
Cons: Continental breakfast: pastries dry, no fruit, no brown sugar.
9.0
Verified Hotel Guest
Wonderful
Traveling as Couple
02-17-2016
Pros: Swimming in the indoor pool was amazing at the coldest night of the year!
Cons:
8.3
Anne
Very Good
solo traveller
01-12-2016
Pros: the bed was fine, but they should have comfortable arm chairs in the room instead of just padded table chairs.
Cons: room was right off the lobby and there was a loud talker in the lobby late at night...not sure if it was a guest or staff.
10.0
Lauren
Exceptional
Family with Teens
11-30-2015
Pros: Room was clean & didn't smell "institutional." Staff was friendly and warm. Continental breakfast was good.
Cons: n/a
8.0
Robert
Very Good
mature couple
09-08-2015
Pros: The room had a smell of smoke, but they offered us another room. Very good service. Was clean in general.
Cons: Just need an elevator for second floor. And breakfast should be open till 10:00 am
7.9
Thomas
Good
mature couple
09-08-2015
Pros: the helpful, cheerful, professional staff, especially checking in and checking out
Cons: some road noise from the NY Thruway and poor lighting over the sink.
10.0
Wayne
Exceptional
mature couple
08-20-2015
Pros: Great breakfast, clean room, friendly staff
Cons:
8.0
Verified Hotel Guest
Very Good
Traveling as Couple
08-12-2015
Pros: It was fine
Cons: Nothing special
5.0
Carlos
Fair
mature couple
07-02-2015
Pros: Excellent service and cleanliness at breakfast.
Cons: Pool was closed for painting (in June!!?). Tub drain did not work properly. Lateral hallways crowded with laundry carts.
5.8
Geoffrey
Okay
review category group of friends
06-12-2015
Pros: New facility with decent bed and breakfast
Cons: Full of kids overtaking the pool all hours
7.1
Lucy
Good
mature couple
06-10-2015
Pros: aging property but well kept ,paid 124.00 for a room . similar room previous 6 nights of our cross country trip 75.00 to 85.00...
Cons:
7.5
Matthew
Good
mature couple
06-01-2015
Pros: Courteous staff. And rooms were clean
Cons:
9.6
Oldnavyguy
Exceptional
mature couple
05-17-2015
Pros: Locatiion was good for our plans. A couple of miles to some good eateries.
Cons: Could have been a little closer in. Was almost a remote locatiion.
10.0
Anonymous
Exceptional
mature couple
04-18-2015
Pros: Excellent value for money. We are on a road trip to Montreal from New York and this hotel made an excellent base for the Catskill region. The facilities for the price were amazing - ie. Swimming pool and a big choice of food for breakfast.
Cons:
5.0
Anonymous
Fair
mature couple
10-21-2014
Pros: Our room was clean
Cons: Fitness equipment was broken. Hairdryer in our room was broken (no working switch - handle heated up). Poor Wi-Fi. Hallway carpets were filthy. Hallways were littered with rolling bins of used linens. We feared the free breakfast, so we ate out.
10.0
Yvonne
Exceptional
review category group of friends
09-25-2014
Pros: the room was nice , comfortable. Right next to pool and Jacuzi , Staff very helpful
Cons: the eggs were terrible , hard/rubbery. tasted kind of fake actually
;detailController.handleFacebook('SEO','Best Western New Baltimore Inn', '115596', 'ACCOMMODATION', '2', '', '', 'http://tdr.aaa.com/tdr-images/images/property_photo/accommodation/115596H1.jpg', 'West Coxsackie', '', '', '', '');){kind=link}
;detailController.handleTwitter('SEO','Best Western New Baltimore Inn', '115596', 'ACCOMMODATION', '2', '', 'http://tdr.aaa.com/tdr-images/images/property_photo/accommodation/115596H1.jpg', 'West Coxsackie', '', '', '', '');){kind=link}