Carlisle Inn Sugarcreek

AAA Inspector Rating
8.7
Exceptional
517 Guest Ratings
1357 Old Route 39
Sugarcreek, OH 44681- Map It
Photos
X
AAA Inspector Rating Details (scale 1-5)
3.4
Overall
Room3.3
Bath3.3
Public Areas3.6
ARATED
AAA Inspector Notes
Inspector Pick (Family friendly): The on-site theater shows family and kid friendly shows year round, which range from religious-themed plays and concerts to ventriloquists.
Located in the heart of the largest Amish community in the country, this inn boasts elegant rooms with patios or balconies in a charming rural setting. Enjoy a play at the in-house theater June through December or relax on the deck overlooking the countryside. The bright, indoor pool area is decorated with live plants and has a retractable roof that is opened on sunny days. Smoke free premises. 69 units, some two bedrooms. 4 stories, interior corridors. Accessibility (Call).

Amenities & Services

WiFi
Swimming Pool
Pets Allowed
Fitness Center
ECO Friendly
Electric Charging
Accessible
Business Center
Type
Country Inn
Location
I-77 exit 83, 7 mi w. 1357 Old Route 39 44681 (PO Box 525).
Pool
heated indoor.
Dining & Entertainment
Dutch Valley Restaurant, see separate listing.
Business Services
Available on premises
Room Amenities
refrigerators, coffeemakers, high-speed Internet, wireless Internet. Some: microwaves.
Sports & Recreation
hot tub, exercise room, massage.
Guest Services
coin laundry.
Terms
N

Guest Ratings

OVERALL GUEST SCORE
Exceptional
Based on Ratings from 517 guests
Showing reviews 1 - 5 of 50
10.0
Anonymous
Exceptional
08-11-2017
Amazing staff. When we arrived we were told we missed snack hour, but we're asked if we just like the cookies brought to our room. We wanted to purchase the quilts and art work from our room. The staff looked to see if they had any new items we could purchase from them. They did not, but instead of moving on they have us the details and the local stores where we might be able to purchase. We had a wonderful time sitting in the public areas just reading. Completely peaceful and refreshing. Awesome location too. Plenty of great shopping and dining in the same complex as the hotel. We even enjoyed borrowing one of the movies they have available.
Pros: Incredibly relaxing environment. Lived up to its advertisements. Refreshing two day "vacation!"
Cons: The hot tub was subpar, but that wasn't a huge draw to begin with.
8.0
Anonymous
Very Good
08-11-2017
Pros: Very nice newly built hotel. The staff was very friendly and helpful. Breakfast was very good with a variety of options.
Cons: The Hot Tube was not working during our stay.
10.0
Anonymous
Exceptional
08-11-2017
Pros: Our stay was wonderfull, The staff treated us like we were very special. We plan to go back in October. I would recommend the Carlisle to anyone needing a beautiful, quite and peacefull place to stay.
Cons: Not being able to stay longer.
10.0
Anonymous
Exceptional
08-11-2017
Pros: Met or exceeded our expectations on all levels
Cons: Only one little quirk. They had free popcorn in the sitting area. It was not fresh. They had the machine, but filled the dispensing area with stale bulk popcorn out of a huge bag. Sort of cheesy
8.3
Anonymous
Very Good
04-21-2016
Loved it and the view...
Pros: We ended up staying at the Carlisle Inn in Walnut Creek for only one night as we had a medical crises and needed to return home. The above is rated for the inn in Walnut Creek.
Cons: We would have liked a pool.
Showing reviews 1 - 5 of 50