One If by Land, Two If by Sea

Historic. Originally an 18th-century carriage house owned by Aaron Burr—Alexander Hamilton's deadly dueling foe—the period details of the lovely interiors and the courtyard make for a memorably romantic, candlelit setting. Diners can enjoy classic meals like steak au poivre, grilled lamb chops, seared tuna, and sweet and savory foie gras. As you dine and soak in the history, a pianist plays the New York standards. The large windows at the front of the restaurant open in summer to the small narrow street, with a lounge and small tables comfortably spread together from which to soak in a sublime atmosphere on a warm night. The fireplace is lit in winter and is a centerpiece of the room. In such a setting one can easily imagine a time of horses trotting along on the cobblestoned side street, in an earlier American age. It is no wonder that this storied restaurant has garnered such a fondness from diners over the many years. A New York gem.