Home / In Depth / Best Places to Stay Near Mallory Square in Key West

Best Places to Stay Near Mallory Square in Key West

Florida Keys News Bureau/Bob Krist
By AAA Travel Editors
January 11, 2022
If Las Vegas has the strip and New York has the city, then Key West claims the sunset over the Gulf. At each of these inns and resorts, you’ll be close to the legendary Key West Sunset Celebration at Mallory Square (400 Wall St.) but can easily retreat to a more secluded twilight moment in your well-appointed room if you so choose. Budget travelers, take note: Many Key West hotels and inns have resort fees and/or parking fees that can increase the nightly cost of the guest room.
iStockphoto.com /amirae

Amsterdam's Curry Mansion Inn

511 Caroline St.
(305) 294-5349
For a sense of history, try this late-1800s historic mansion complete with antique furniture and enhancements like a complimentary evening cocktail party. Even though the structure operates as an inn, it’s still Florida-style, so the home has a sweeping wraparound front porch, a small swimming pool and hot tub. There’s also a full daily breakfast.
Book Now
Courtesy of Hyatt Key West Resort & Spa

Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa

601 Front St.
(305) 928-6273
If you’ve ever searched for a place that is upscale without that stuffy, formal edge, this is what it feels like. You can look at the pool or Gulf of Mexico from your lounge chair as the sun sets. You can even bring your furry best friend; the Hyatt advertises itself as a dog-friendly resort.
Book Now
Courtesy of Margaritaville Key West

Opal Key Resort & Marina Key West

245 Front St.
(305) 294-4000
The property is actually built into the extended Mallory Square dock. This is an ideal location for folks who love Old Town Key West, want to be close to everything. They can then plan to come back to a posh night’s sleep, great amenities and room service.
Book Now
Pier House Resort and Spa

Pier House Resort and Spa

One Duval St.
(305) 296-4600
One of the few hotels on the island with its own private beach, the Pier House has a long history of hospitality. Located at the furthest end of Duval Street, this hotel has been a staple in Key West since the 1960s. The hotel features upscale tropical décor and lush landscaped grounds.
Book Now
AAA

Start Your Next Vacation with AAA

AAA Travel provides peace of mind when you travel — before, during and after your vacation! Members enjoy the advantages of membership including exclusive benefits, map routing, savings with the AAA Discounts & Rewards® program as well as recommendations for AAA Diamond-designated hotels and restaurants across the U.S. and Canada. Let AAA provide the rest of your travel needs with AAA Travel Guides, TourBooks®, access to travel agents and counselors and travel insurance. Your next vacation starts with AAA — your complete travel solution. Visit AAA.com/Travel.
X